Canon Sx10
Are videos on the Canon SX10 as good as the one on the Canon Fs100 Video Camera?
I need a nice (not HD) video camera. I decided that an SD-based Canon FS100 would at least be close to the image quality on my old Sony TRV250 Hi-8 camcorder. Rather than pay for the FS100 alone, would the video quality on a New Canon SX10IS be about the same as well as giving me a nice still cam?
You can’t quite get both in a single model, yet.
By spec, The Canon’s movie mode is decent enough… it’s recording at 640×480, which is a “square pixel” version of the standard 720×480 that pretty much all NTSC SD camcorders use… slighly lower pixel count, but it’s not a huge issue. Canon still recording tends to be in same ballpark as lower cost video Camera Video… I have not used this particular model, but in general, I can state this. 30fps will be a bit more “movie like” than the 60i (interlaced) you would get with regular video. If you’re making DVDs, you might notice this, particularly with sports and other fast moving things. If your goal is computer video, the non-interlaced video from the SX100 might actually be preferable (I don’t know if the FS100 has a progressive mode… most of Canon’s HD models do today).
So look at compression.. the SX10 can record 1 hr. 30 min on an 8GB flash card, while the FS100 at top quality can record 1hr. 50min.. That sounds like the SX10 is actually using less compression, but we have to check the format. The FS100 records in MPEG-2, as used on all DVDs. At that bitrate, the FS100 is slightly better than DVD quality.
Checking into the SX10, I find that, like most Digital Still cameras, the SX10 uses Motion-JPEG for video, which is very similar to the DV format. To DV and MJPEG are simpler compression schemes than MPEG-2, so you need more bits per second to get the same quality. DV camcorders use 25Mb/s, while the SX10 is recording around 11Mb/s here. So I would expect this video to be relatively low quality, compared to DVD or the FS100, at least in terms of digital noise (artifacts and other ugly bits due to compression). It might still look fine, but it’s probably more like one of the FS100 “long play” modes rather than top quality.
Next is sound.. most digital still cameras have pretty evil microphones, in mono, and no way to add an external one. The SX10 is a bit better than this.. you can’t add a mic, but at least it’s recording in stereo. Also, the mics are apparently just above the lens housing, and thus less probe to being blocked by your hands (a real problem with many still cameras used for video).
Then there’s “features while recording”. Traditionally, most digital still cameras with Video Recording were not good camcorders, even given their limitations, because some features didn’t work during recording. The first one I had with this mode, a Canon from the 90s, didn’t even keep the viewscreen active. It’s more common for autofocus, autoexposure, and/or zoom to not function while doing video. Some do it.. I have a Panasonic TZ5 which does keep everything active during video, and functions as a somewhat reasonable camcorder (with bad sound and too-high compression, but I have used it as a third video camera on shoots from time to time). So I looked it up, and while it’s not easy to find, one review (included below) did find that auto-focus/exposure remain active during video, and you can zoom. In general, this camera is better designed for video than most.. for example, there’s a separate video button which can be used in any photo mode — most DSCs make you switch to a different “movie mode”, which is a bit annoying (my Panny is like this).
So yeah, I would bet that the SX10 would deliver video comparable to the TRV250, if not quite on par with the FS100. And naturally, the stills will be dramatically better than using the FS100 as a Still Camera. You are limited to 4GB file sizes, which means you get about 40 minutes at top quality before you have to stop shooting, but you can start again right away if you have an 8GB Memory Card (my Panasonic is the same way… it’s because they use the FAT32 file system on the SD card, which is limited to 4GB maximum). With some limitations, it’s going to be decent for casual video use, much better at least than most digital still cameras.
|
|
Canon PowerShot SX10 IS 10.0 Megapixel Digital Camera $99.99 |
|
|
Canon PowerShot SX10 IS 10.0 MP Digital Camera – Black $150.00 |
|
|
Canon PowerShot SX10 IS 10.0 MP Digital Camera – Black $117.50 |
|
|
Canon PowerShot SX10 IS Camera $190.00 |
|
|
Canon PowerShot SX10 IS 10.0 MP Digital Camera – Black $145.00 |
|
|
CANON POWER SHOT SX10is 10.0MEGA PIXELS CAMERA *LOOK* $60.00 |
|
|
Vivitar 2GB Accessory Kit for Canon Powershot SX10IS Digital Camera $54.99 |
|
|
Canon PowerShot SX10 IS 10.0 MP Digital Camera – Black $150.00 |
|
|
Canon PowerShot SX10 IS 10.0 Megapixel Digital Camera $99.99 |
|
|
Canon PowerShot SX10 IS 10.0 MP Digital Camera – Black $99.00 |
|
|
Canon PowerShot SX10 IS 10.0 MP Digital Camera – Black $89.00 |
|
|
LikeNew Canon PowerShot SX10 IS Digital Camera 20x Optical Zoom $245.95 |
|
|
Canon Powershot SX10 IS Digital Camera in Original Box with Accessories NR!! $36.00 |
|
|
As is – Lens Error Canon PowerShot SX10 IS 10.0 MP Digital Camera – Black $40.00 |
|
|
Canon PowerShot SX10 IS 10.0 MP Digital Camera – Black $195.00 |
|
|
Canon PowerShot SX10 IS 10.0 MP Digital Camera – Black $210.00 |
|
|
Canon PowerShot SX10 IS 10.0 MP Digital Camera – Black $66.01 |
|
|
Canon PowerShot BLACK Mini Glove Bag Carrying Sleeve For Slim Digital Camera and Camera Accessories: models Canon PowerShot SD1200IS, Canon PowerShot SX200IS, Canon PowerShot D10, SD890IS, SD780IS, $10.85 Prevents your camera case from getting scratches while inside your brief case or tote bag. Made from soft Neoprene material!!! Perfect case to protect your camera since it stretches to form-fit your camera!!! Digital Camera Screen Guard is Perfect to protect your cameras screen from scratches and dirty prints!!! Vangoddy TM(Trademarked) WristBand states Live*Laugh*Love on the front with Vangoddytm… |
|
|
Battery-Biz Inc. Duracell AA NiMH rechargeable blister pack, 4 per pkg. $5.23 AA Cell NiMH Rechargeable Duracell Battery 4 Pack… |
|
|
6 Volt NiCad Laptop Battery $40.95 Battery-Biz is a leading manufacturer and distributor of batteries, adapters and chargers and the industry’s source for Hi-Capacity(TM) brand power products. Hi-Capacity(TM) products are made using the finest components available and carry a one year warranty against defects in material and workmanship. Hi-Capacity(TM) products are guaranteed to meet or exceed original specifications. Fits APP… |
|
|
Mobile PowerFlex Car Travel Power Adapter for your Canon / Sony / Sanyo and MANY other Camcorders! Includes Micro USB cable $43.99 The Mobile PowerFlex is your solution to re-charging your camcorder on-the-go! The PowerFlex’s intuitive, easy-to-use operation makes re-charging your video camera a breeze. Simply plug the PowerFlex into your car’s DC Outlet. Then, plug your AC Adapter into the PowerFlex and instantly you have complete mobile power. The Mobile PowerFlex works with:Canon VIXIA HF S10 / HF R10 / HF S200 / FS300 / H… |
|
|
Transcend 16 GB SDHC Class 10 Flash Memory Card TS16GSDHC10E $13.99 Transcend 16GB Class 10 SDHC Flash Memory Card (TS16GSDHC10E) – Frustration Free Package Certified Frustration-Free Packaging Amazon.com has certified this product’s packaging is Frustration-Free. A Frustration-Free Package is easy-to-open and comes without excess packaging materials such as hard plastic “clamshell” casings, plastic bindings, and wire ties. It is exactly the same as a tradition… |
|
|
Transcend 8GB Class 10 SDHC Flash Memory Card $8.37 … |
|
|
Power2000 1200Mah Lithium Battery Replacement For Canon NB-10L Battery (For Canon SX40 HS Camera) $3.99 Hi Capacity 1200Mah Lithium Battery Replacement For Canon NB-10L Battery ( For Canon SX40 HS Camera)… |
|
|
Lowepro Rezo 60 Camera Case (Black) $9.99 LowePro Rezo 60 Camera Case Equip your camera with the tough protection it needs. Sophisticated yet lightweight, the LowePro Rezo 60 Camera Case in Black will do the job. It includes many features found in larger bags, such as zippered compartments, inner pockets for memory, batteries or small accessories. It also comes with a SlipLock attachment tab and adjustable shoulder strap…. |
|
|
Lowepro Ridge 30 Camera Case (Arctic Blue) $7.99 RAK)LOWEPRO RIDGE 30 ARTIC BLUE CASE… |
|
|
8 GB 8gig 8GB SD (SDHC) Secure Digital High Capacity Flash Memory Card $6.65 - 8GB Secure Digital Memory Card, for use in Nintendo Wii - SDHC High Speed Class Rating: Class 6 - Built-in write-protect switch prevents accidental data loss - Low Power Consumption (10,000 insertion / removal cycles - Supports Content Protection for Recordable Media (CPRM) for music and other commercial media… |
